The Alabama Digest
Wednesday, March 22, 2023
  • Login
  • Main News
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Main News
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The Alabama Digest
No Result
View All Result
Home Main News

Opinion | Manmade laws can be flawed. Accomplice liability is one of them

Doris Lewis by Doris Lewis
October 6, 2022
in Main News
0
Opinion | Manmade laws can be flawed. Accomplice liability is one of them
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Opinion | Manmade laws can be flawed. Accomplice liability is one of them

News stories float constantly on the surface of social media, bobbing up and down, in and out of sight. Some stories sink eventually.

RELATED POSTS

Supporting Ukraine through Consumer Power: The Initiatives Keeping Its Economy Afloat

January 24 in Alabama’s history: What happened on the day

But not Lakeith Smith’s story, which has been resurfacing since at least 2018. That’s when he was sentenced to 65 years in prison for felony murder, burglary and theft. One year later, his prison time was reduced to 55 years due to a legal technicality.

The correction that should have been made, however, wasn’t. Couldn’t be, I guess. Because it was within the law. But that doesn’t mean it was right.

So, I’ll say it. Smith should not have been charged with felony murder. He shouldn’t have been charged because he didn’t kill anyone.

Literally. He didn’t kill a soul.

Yet, because of Alabama’s accomplice liability law, a person doesn’t actually have to be a killer to be convicted of murder. A person just has to be adjacent to one as the awful deed is being done.

Even if that killer is a police officer.

Smith’s story truly is a twisted tale. It starts with brazen acts of juvenile delinquency committed by Smith and his cohorts in 2015. He and several other young teens – Jadarien Hardy, Jhavarske Jackson and La’Anthony Washington – were believed to have been responsible for several break-ins in Millbrook.

During the last break-in attempt, a police officer intervened. Washington and the officer reportedly exchanged shots. The teen was killed.

That’s when Alabama’s accomplice liability law kicked in, making him and the other teens legally accountable for Washington’s death.

Again, they didn’t kill him. The officer did. And as far as we know, all of them were willing participants in the break-ins.

“The officer shot A’donte, not Lakeith Smith,” said Washington’s attorney Jennifer Holton during the trial. “Lakeith was a 15-year-old child, scared to death. He did not participate in the act that caused the death of A’donte. He never shot anybody.”

The other teens only got 25-year sentences thanks to their plea agreements. Which may mean that Smith was penalized for not pleading to a murder he hadn’t committed.

Another problem with this case is that the police officer’s shooting of Mr. Washington was ruled justifiable.

Think about that for a second. An internal investigation justified the shooting death of Washington, but Smith still was penalized – for the shooting death of Washington. Even though he didn’t pull the trigger.

How in God’s name does that make sense, or mesh with justice?

This is just one nonsensical, unjust outcome for a law that was crafted presumably to tighten the neck around accomplices to crimes. Even without a law enforcement background, I can see a benefit to ensuring that accomplices to crimes can’t just waltz away.

But not if it makes shooters indistinguishable from non-shooters. Not if it treats thieving teenagers like cold-blooded killers.

We have been conditioned to believe that manmade laws are sacrosanct. Like they were crafted by the hands of Jehovah on Mount Sinai and handed down to Moses in a holy blaze of fire and smoke.

But manmade laws aren’t divine. They can be flawed. Sometimes, they need to be repealed. Others just need to be modified.

To keep us from compounding injustice.

The laws I’m talking about are difficult to defend when the impact on real human beings is measured. Alabama’s accomplice liability law is one of them.

Lakeith Smith made some bad decisions when he was 15. He may have made more as his case was being adjudicated.

But those decisions didn’t make him a killer. Yet the law strangely, perversely transferred the guilt and penalty forWashington’s death to Smith, whose only actual crimes were burglary, theft, and being an immature, insolent teenager.

God help us if that’s justice in Alabama.

ShareTweetPin
Doris Lewis

Doris Lewis

Related Posts

Supporting Ukraine through Consumer Power: The Initiatives Keeping Its Economy Afloat

Supporting Ukraine through Consumer Power: The Initiatives Keeping Its Economy Afloat

by Alice Trout
February 6, 2023
0

Amid the Russian invasion, Ukrainian creatives are taking matters into their own hands to keep the country's economy going. Fashion...

January 24 in Alabama’s history: What happened on the day

January 24 in Alabama’s history: What happened on the day

by Alice Trout
January 24, 2023
0

January 24th has seen a few significant events in Alabama's history. Here are a few notable examples: In 1861, Alabama...

Staying Informed: The Top 10 Most Popular News Websites on the East Coast of the United States”

Staying Informed: The Top 10 Most Popular News Websites on the East Coast of the United States”

by Alice Trout
January 19, 2023
0

The East Coast of the United States is home to some of the most dynamic and influential news outlets in...

Healthcare Advertising in Alabama: Ensuring Access to Accurate and Reliable Information

Healthcare Advertising in Alabama: Ensuring Access to Accurate and Reliable Information

by Alice Trout
January 3, 2023
0

Healthcare advertising plays a crucial role in informing and educating the public about important medical treatments and products, but it...

Supporting Mental Health in Alabama’s Startup Community

Supporting Mental Health in Alabama’s Startup Community

by Alice Trout
December 29, 2022
0

As the startup scene in Alabama continues to grow and thrive, it's important to prioritize the mental health and well-being...

Next Post
Broadband expansion to reach “every Alabama address” within six years

Broadband expansion to reach “every Alabama address” within six years

Opinion | Our country will regret the Biden student loan “forgiveness” program

Opinion | Our country will regret the Biden student loan “forgiveness” program

RECOMMENDED

Supporting Ukraine through Consumer Power: The Initiatives Keeping Its Economy Afloat

Supporting Ukraine through Consumer Power: The Initiatives Keeping Its Economy Afloat

February 6, 2023
January 24 in Alabama’s history: What happened on the day

January 24 in Alabama’s history: What happened on the day

January 24, 2023

MOST VIEWED

  • More details emerge in politico Perry O. Hooper’s arrest

    More details emerge in politico Perry O. Hooper’s arrest

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Danielle: meaning of a name

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • AG’s office: We didn’t hide witness investigation

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Healthcare Advertising in Alabama: Ensuring Access to Accurate and Reliable Information

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • New director to form partnerships that support industry, boost UA

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
The Alabama Digest

CATEGORY

  • Main News

SITE LINKS

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
  • Main News
  • Contact Us

© 2022 thealabamadigest.com.

No Result
View All Result
  • Main News
  • Contact Us

© 2022 thealabamadigest.com.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In